Automoderated users, Bots, Bureaucrats, checkuser, Comment administrators, Moderators, Administrators
9,546
edits
Noor Al-Ain fi Mashhad Al-Hussain: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
no edit summary
(Created page with "{{Infobox book | name = Noor Al-Ain fi Mashhad Al-Hussain | image = Noor Al-Ain fi Mashhad Al-Hussain.jpg | caption = | alt = | author = Abu Ishaq Esfarayeni | title_orig...") |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 51: | Line 51: | ||
== The value and importance of books == | == The value and importance of books == | ||
Perhaps few books or Maqtals can be found in the history of Karbala and the uprising of Ashura, such as Noor al-Ain, that there is such a consensus among scholars about the widespread distortions in it. As stated in one interpretation, much of the material in the book in question is so unreliable and irrational that it is unlikely that it would have been written by a scientist jurist. In the book “ Tahghigh dar bare Aval Arba’een –e- Hazrat-e- Sayyid Al-Shuhada",<ref>Mohammadi Rey Shahri, p.63</ref> Ghazi Tabatabai also refers to Noor al-Ain or “The Maqtal-e- Esfarayeni”, as a very unreliable book, and says the book is "A Sea of Falsehoods and Lies."<ref>Qazi Tabatabai, p.50</ref> | Perhaps few books or Maqtals can be found in the history of Karbala and the uprising of Ashura, such as Noor al-Ain, that there is such a consensus among scholars about the widespread distortions in it. As stated in one interpretation, much of the material in the book in question is so unreliable and irrational that it is unlikely that it would have been written by a scientist jurist. In the book “ [[Tahghigh Darbare Rooz-e- Arbaʽeen-e- Hazrat Sayyid al-Shuhada|Tahghigh dar bare Aval Arba’een –e- Hazrat-e- Sayyid Al-Shuhada]]",<ref>Mohammadi Rey Shahri, p.63</ref> [[Ghazi Tabatabai]] also refers to Noor al-Ain or “The Maqtal-e- Esfarayeni”, as a very unreliable book, and says the book is "A Sea of Falsehoods and Lies."<ref>Qazi Tabatabai, p.50</ref> | ||
== Sources == | == Sources == | ||