Ali b. al-Hussain: Difference between revisions

==The Aftermath of Karbala==

In Medina Ali led a pious life which earned him the honorifics Zayn al-Abidin, al-Sajjad (“he who constantly prostrates himself”), al-Zaki (“the pure”) and Dhu ’l-Thafinat (referring to the calluses on his skin in the places touching the ground in prostration). Whenever the time of prayer drew near, he would tremble and go pale, and his devotional practices caused fears for his Health. He was counted among the bakkaʾun [q.v.], since for years he would weep for his father and the other martyrs of Karbala. He used to go out at night with his face covered in order to distribute charity (ṣadaqat al-sirr), and it was only after his death that people discovered the identity of their benefactor. When his body was washed, marks were found on his shoulders, the result of his carrying heavy loads of food at night for the poor.

Ali studiously avoided any involvement with the authorities and adopted a quiescent attitude towards the Umayyads and the Zubayrid anti-caliphate. Shiʿi authors maintain that Ali’s dealings with the authorities were based on taqiyya. Ali proved magnanimous even when wronged: Hisham b. Ismaʿil used to insult him during his four years as governor of Medina, yet after Hisham’s dismissal by al-Walid (7 Rabiʿ I 87/26 February 706) Ali forbade his family and friends to speak ill of him. A famous story has it that when the future caliph Hisham b. Abd al-Malik came to Mecca on pilgrimage, he was unable to approach the Kaʿba because of the crowds; for Ali, however, the crowds parted, allowing him unhindered access. On that occasion, al-Farazdaq [q.v.] is said to have improvised a poem in praise of Ali, thereby arousing Hisham’s ire; but the eulogy, which exists in various versions, has been judged to be mostly or entirely unauthentic. <ref>see J. Hell, “Al-Farazdaḳs Loblied auf ʿAli ibn al-Ḥusain,” Festschrift Eduard Sachau, Berlin, 1915, pp. 368-74; J. Weiss in Der Islam VII, 1917, pp. 126ff.</ref>

His relations with Mukhtar, the Shiʿite rebel in Kufa, were cautious. It is unlikely that (as some sources state) the latter originally offered to put his movement under the auspices of Ali b. Hussain, rather than of his uncle Muhammad b. Hanafiya, or that he sent the head of Omar b. Saʿd to him, rather than to his uncle. In Sunnite collections of Hadith Ali b. Hussain appears as a transmitter from Abdallah b. Abbas, his uncle Hasan, his father, Amr b. Othman, and others. The chief transmitter from him was Zohri, who is said to have described him as the most excellent of the Hashimites. He was involved in a dispute with his cousin Hasan b. Hasan about the administration of the sadaqat of Ali b. Abi Talib but soon agreed to leave it to the Hasanid; nevertheless, Imamite sources maintain that he became the administrator of Ali’s sadaqat.